Site icon Project Spring

FUNDAMENTAL HUMAN RIGHTS AND THE LIMITATIONS IN THE ERA OF COVID19 PANDEMIC IN NIGERIA

admin

FUNDAMENTAL HUMAN RIGHTS AND THE LIMITATIONS IN THE ERA OF COVID19 PANDEMIC IN NIGERIA

ABSTRACT

Humanrightsarethoseprivilegeswhicheveryindividualisentitledtobyreason ofbeingahumanbeing.Ontheotherhand,fundamentalhumanrightsareprivileges entrenchedinthelawsofacountry,ofwhichitscitizensandindividualslivingtherein areentitledto.Fundamentalhumanrightsareundoubtedlyanecessarycreationforthe evasionofananarchical,barbaricandlawlesssociety.Notwithstanding,therearestill legallimitationstotheserights.Theselimitationsamongstotherreasonsexistto ensurethattheenjoymentofanindividual’srightdoesnotleadtotheinfringementof another’sright.Consequently,thisresearchispartlyfocusedatlookingthoroughlyat theserights,theirlimitationsgenerally,andalsospecificallyduringtheCovid19 pandemicinNigeria.WorthyofnoteisthefactthatthroughouttheeraoftheCovid19 pandemic,nostateofemergencywasdeclaredinNigeria.Theresearcherfocusedon thefailuretodeclareastateofemergency,thenexaminedtheconditionsforthe declarationofastateofemergencyandacomparativeexaminationoftheexerciseof emergencypowersinNigeria.Theresearchmethodologyemployedissolelydoctrinal, thus,caselawsandstatuteswouldbedescribedandanalyzed,withtheexclusionofany fieldwork.

 

CHAPTERONE

INTRODUCTION

1.1BACKGROUNDTOTHESTUDY

Fundamentalhumanrightsareprivilegesentrenchedinthelawsofacountry,of whichitscitizensandindividualslivingthereinareentitledto.Humanrightsasawhole hasitsinceptiontracedto539BCwhenCyrusthegreatmadecertaindeclarations.[1]Withsocialevolutioncamethedevelopmentofotherrightsacrossalljurisdictions;from theinternationalspheredowntothenationalsphere.Notably,thefundamentalhuman rightsfoundinthelawsofvariousnationsaremainlytracedtothoserightsinthe internationalsphere.

TheNigerianConstitutionisthelawwhichharborsthevariousfundamental rightsofthenationNigeria.Theserightswhichnumber12intotalarefoundinChapter IVofthe1999ConstitutionoftheFederalRepublicofNigeria(CFRN).Forthepurpose ofenforcement,thecourtshavebeenconferredwiththemandateofdoingso.

Generally,inNigeriaaswellasothernations,thelimitingoftheserightswould subjecttheoffendertosanctions.Notwithstanding,therearevariousinstancesinthese nations,wherethelimitingofsuchrightswouldnotamounttoanunlawfulact warrantingsanctions.Therearevariousreasonsforsuchlimitationswhichareaptly capturedintheexceptionsoften.Apopularrationaleisconnotedinthestatementof JusticeOliverWendellHolmes.Hesaid:“Therighttoswingmyfistsendswherethe otherman’snosebegins”.[2]Theaboveconnotesthatthough“A”hasacertainright,in theinstancewhere“B’s”rightwouldbeviolatedonthegroundofA’senjoymentofhis, A’srightshouldbelimited.

TheeraoftheCovid19pandemicinNigeriareiteratedthefactthattheserights arenotabsolute.Rightssuchastherighttomovement,religion,expression,association etc.werealllimited.Theselimitationswouldbeplacedonthescaleofthelawinthis thesistodetermineiftheymatchuplawfully.

AloomingquestioninNigeriawhichhassubsistedthroughouttheCovid19erais whetherthefailurebythegovernmenttodeclareastateofemergencywasproper.A stateofemergencywhichisbestdefinedbydescriptionreferstoasituationofnational dangerordisasterinwhichagovernmentsuspendsnormalconstitutionalproceduresin ordertoregaincontrol.[3][4]InNigeria,thePresidentisthesoleindividualempoweredto issueastateofemergency.Thisisinaccordancewithsection305(1)ofthe1999CFRN asamended.Consideringthedefinitionofastateofemergency,iftheNigerian Presidentweretoissuesuchaproclamation,thiswouldmeanamoretight-fisted controlofitscitizensandaliens.ItwasevidentthatNigeriaCentreforDiseaseControl (NCDC)guidelinesonCovid19wereflouteddespitethevariouspetitionsbythe governmentforcitizenstoobey.

ThefloutingoftheNCDCguidelinesasstatedabove,withtheconsequential effectsofithasbeenamainreasonforthefloatingquestionsomewhatchallengingthe governmentsinaction.Thisthesiswouldseektoresolvethisquestion.

1.2STATEMENTOFTHEPROBLEM

Whenthereissituationofnationaldangerwhichthreatenstheveryexistenceof anationorstate,theidealactionwouldbeforthegovernment(PresidentorGovernor asthecasemaybe)todeclareastateofemergency.Thoughthiswasthepredicament NigeriafacedattheearlystagesoftheCovid19outbreak,nostateofemergencywas declared.Othermeanswere,andarestillbeenutilizedinanattempttocurtailthe predicament.OneofthesemeanswastheinvokingoftheQuarantineActbythe Presidenton29thMarch,2020inLagos,AbujaandOgunstate.[5]A14-daylockdownwas tocommenceasofMarch30thintheabovestateswhichwereadjudgedtocontribute thehighestpercentagetoCovidcasesintheNation.Anotherschemeemployedwasthe continuousadmonishmentbytheChairmanofthePresidentialTaskForceonCovid19, BossMustapha,forthecitizenstofollowtheNigeriaCentreforDiseaseControl(NCDC) guidelinesonCovid19.TherewasalsoconstantcounselbyStateGovernorsonthe needforcompliancewiththeCovid19protocols.

Despitethepresenceoftheabovemeasures,thecountryisstillfacingthe aforementionedpredicament.Thisloomingproblemhasledtoalotofknownand unknowndeaths.Ithasalsocausedindividualstobeisolatedfromtheirfamilies unwillingly.ThecountryhasalsobeenputonalistofnationsinUnitedKingdomof whichitcitizenswouldrequirea10dayquarantinebeforebeingallowedintothesociety. Thisprohibitionhasrecentlybeenlifted.Asaresultoftheseprevailingissuescausedby theCovid19virus,thisthesisisfocusedonprovidingasolutiontotheproblem.

1.3AIMSANDOBJECTIVES

Theaimofthisthesisistodiscusstheconceptoffundamentalhumanrightsas wellasthelimitationstheretointheeraoftheCovid19pandemicinNigeria.The followingaretheobjectivessetouttobeachieved:

ExtentofitsSurvivalundertheQuarantineAct1926[2020]

1.4SCOPEANDLIMITATIONOFSTUDY

Thisthesiswillfocusontheemergenceanddevelopmentoffundamentalhuman right.Withregardstothelegislationswhichwouldbediscussed,onlyinternationallaws anddomesticlawsinNigeriawouldbeconsidered.Thediscussionoftheexceptionsto thefundamentalhumanrightsasseenduringtheCovid19pandemicwouldbelimited toitspresenceinNigeria.

Thelimitationsfacedinthisstudyincludeselectingasinglereferencematerial outofconflictingonesandthelackofproperidentificationforcertainrelevantmaterials whichservedasreferencematerials.

1.5SIGNIFICANCEOFTHESTUDY

Aclearpresentationofthefactthatfundamentalhumanrightsarenotabsolute woulddoawaywiththepreconceivednotionstilllingeringintheheartsofsomewellmeaningNigerians.Covid19hasbroughtalongsideitanentourageofproblems,hence, providingasolutiontoreduceitseffectsiswhatthisthesisseekstoachieve.

1.6RESEARCHMETHODOLOGY

Theresearchmethodologyemployedisdoctrinal.Thismethodologyinvolvesthe useofprimaryandsecondaryresearchmaterials.Theprimarysourcesincludecase laws,internationalanddomesticlaws.Thesecondarymaterialsontheotherhand includesourcessuchasarticles,textbooksandjournalsborderingonthethesis.

1.7LITERATUREREVIEW

Thearticletitled‘HumanRightsevolution,abriefhistory’writtenbyMarcoSutto[6]standsshouldershighamongstothersofsimilarsubject.Theaforementionedarticle dealtsuccinctlywiththehistoricaldevelopmentofhumanrightsaswellascertain pivotalinternationalstatutesborderingonhumanrights.Hisworkwasthusanonnegotiablereferencepiece

A.M.Adebayo’sannotatedversionofthe1999ConstitutionoftheFederal

RepublicofNigeria[7]isagotoareaforfundamentalhumanrightsinNigeriaandtheir exceptions.Thebookisfilledwithalltheprovisionsonfundamentalhumanrightsin Nigeriaaswellascaselawsborderingoneach.Byreasonofthefactthatthe exceptionstothefundamentalhumanrightsareboxedupintheveryrightsthemselves, Adebayo’sworkwasofgreatimport.

MagnusL.andMarkKarticleon‘Asmanystateofemergencydeclarations duringthefirstwaveofthepandemicasintheprecedingdecade’wasalsoreviewed. Thisarticledealtsuccinctlywiththeamountofstateofemergeicneswhichwere declaredduringthefirstwaveoftheCovid19outbreak.Thisinformationwasnecessary inconductingthisresearch.

TheBackgroundofHumanRightswrittenbyYouthforHumanRightswas anotherresearchmaterialconsulted.BesidesmakingreferencetoMarcoSutto’swork onthehistoricaldevelopmentofhumanrights,YouthforHumanRightsarticlestated abovewasalsoused.

HansBetal,‘StatesofEmergency’wasalsoconsulted.Hisworkwas instrumentalinprovidngsufficientmaterialsonstateofemergency.

‘ObasanjoDeclaresStateofEmergencyinPlateauState’writtenbyTheNew Humanitarianwasapivotalmaterialincomprehendingwhattookplaceduringthestate ofemergencydeclared.

Whilesearchingformaterialswhichdiscussedstateofemergenciesdeclaredin othercountries,AmnestyInternational’sarticleon‘Thailand’sStateofEmergency shouldnotInfringeonHumanRights’wasmadeuseof.

Inmakingreferencetomaterialwhichdealtwithreasonsforlimitationsof fundamentalhumanrights,Caplan’sarticleonLibertyhasitsResponsibilitieswasused. However,itwasnotasdetailedasexpected.

Thearticleonthecomparativeexaminationofexerciseofemergencypowers (Nigeria,IndiaandEgypt)writtenbyDamfeboK.DerriandPerekedouJamesFaweiwas anothermaterialused.Thisworkwasconsideredbecauseitisapivotalmaterialwhen dealingwithstateofemergencyinNigeria,IndiaandEgypt.Byreasonofthefactthat thisresearchbordersonstateofemergencyinabovementionedcountries,thiswork wascritical.

SegunDawoduarticleon‘TheCrisisinWesternNigeria’wasmadereferenceto. Thisarticledealtextensivelyonthehappeningswhichswelleduptothedeclarationofa stateofemergencyinNigeriaundertheTafawaBalewagovernmentintheyear1962.

Otherliteraryworkswouldbeconsideredduringthedetailedexplanationofthe varioussubheadings.

1.8SYNOPSISOFCHAPTERS

Thisthesisisdividedintofivechapterswhichinsuchmanner:

ChapterOneistheintroductorypartofthisthesis.ChapterTwodealswiththe conceptualandhistoricalframework.ChapterThreeontheotherhandisconcerned withthelegalframeworkoffundamentalhumanrights.ChapterFourcontainsthe problemofwhichthisthesisseekstoresolveandthevariousmeasuresputinplacein anattempttoresolvetheissuewerealsoappraised.ChapterFiveconcludesby summarizingtheprecedingchapters,statingsomeobservationsandmaking recommendations.

[1] M.Sutto,HumanRightsevolution,abriefhistory(2019)TheCoESPUMAGAZINE

<https://www.coespu.org/index.php/articles/human-rights-evolution-brief-history>accessed3

September2021

[2] A.Caplan,LibertyhasitsResponsibilities(2013)

<https://www.Tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.4161/hv.26252?scroll=top&needAccess=true>accessed3 September2021

[3] Simpson,J.,2021.Stateofemergency.In: OxfordDictionary,2nded.[online]NewYork:Clarendon

Press,p.1.Availableat:<https://www.lexico.com/definition/state_of_emergency>Accessed8October

[4]

[5] M.A.EdwinASynopticOverviewoftheQuarantineAct;ThePresidentsDirectiveonStatesandthe

[6] M.Sutto,HumanRightsevolution,abriefhistory(2019)TheCoESPUMAGAZINE

<https://www.coespu.org/index.php/articles/human-rights-evolution-brief-history>accessed3 September2021

[7] AdesanyaAdebayo,1999ConstitutionoftheFederalRepublicofNigeria(PrincetonPublishingCompany 2012)

FUNDAMENTAL HUMAN RIGHTS AND THE LIMITATIONS IN THE ERA OF COVID19 PANDEMIC IN NIGERIA

Exit mobile version